Federal Court Temporarily Enjoins Enforcement of Arizona's Controversial Immigration Law

On July 28, 2010, the U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona issued a highly anticipated order in United States v. State of Arizona, a recent federal lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the Arizona “Support of Law Enforcement and Safe Neighborhoods Act” (“SB 1070”). The order temporarily enjoins enforcement of certain provisions of SB 1070 pending the court’s final ruling in the matter. To learn more, please continue reading Littler's ASAP, What Arizona's Controversial Immigration Law Means for Employers, by Neil M. Alexander and Michael J. Lehet.

Obama Administration Urges Supreme Court Review of "Legal Arizona Workers Act"

U.S. Supreme CourtThe Washington Post reports that acting Solicitor General Neil Katyal has submitted a brief (pdf) on behalf of the Obama administration urging the U.S. Supreme Court to review and invalidate the Legal Arizona Workers Act (LAWA), a 2008 law that imposes sanctions far greater than those prescribed by federal law on employers that hire illegal immigrants (Note: LAWA is a different law than Arizona’s recently enacted and controversial immigration enforcement law.). The petition (pdf) for Supreme Court review was originally filed by a coalition that includes the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, civil libertarians and Latino groups.

The brief presents the administration’s position that federal law preempts this state law, and argues that upholding the law would:

"disrupt a careful balance that Congress struck nearly 25 years ago between two interests of the highest importance: ensuring that employers do not undermine enforcement of immigration laws by hiring unauthorized workers, while also ensuring that employers not discriminate against racial and ethnic minorities legally in the country."

Arizona Immigration Law Altered by Subsequent Legislation

The Arizona Daily Star reports that several days after S.B. 1070, Arizona’s controversial immigration bill, became law, the legislature passed H.B. 2162, which clarifies when police officers may inquire into an individual’s immigration status. Under H.B. 2162, an inquiry can occur if:

  • an officer performs a lawful stop, detention or arrest based on a town, city, county or state law; and
  • the officer has reasonable suspicion that a person is an alien and is unlawfully present in the United States.

The language in H.B. 2162 does not amend S.B. 1070; however, when S.B. 1070 takes effect, the revised language in H.B. 2162 will take precedence because it was adopted more recently.

What Arizona's Controversial Immigration Law Means for Employers

State Flag of ArizonaWith many in the nation watching, Arizona Governor Jan Brewer signed the "Support Our Law Enforcement and Safe Neighborhoods Act" ("SB 1070") into law. The legislation represents Arizona's latest effort to combat illegal immigration and is now the centerpiece of a national political firestorm, including criticism from President Obama and numerous public interest groups. In addition, SB 1070 already is the subject of two federal lawsuits challenging its constitutionality. Lost among this debate, however, are those provisions of the law directed toward Arizona employers. To learn more about the law and its implications for employers, please continue reading Littler's ASAP What Arizona's Controversial Immigration Law Means for Employers by Neil M. Alexander and Michael J. Lehet.

Arizona Governor Signs Controversial Immigration Enforcement Bill

Arizona Governor Jan Brewer has signed into law an immigration enforcement bill generally acknowledged to be the “broadest and strictest immigration measure in generations.” The bill has attracted national attention, even drawing strong criticism from President Obama who, according to The Daily Telegraph, has instructed the U.S. Department of Justice to examine the measure’s legality.

Continue Reading...

Controversial Arizona Immigration Bill Sent to Governor

A controversial Arizona immigration enforcement bill (S.B. 1070) moved one step closer to becoming law when the state senate approved the measure on April 19. The bill has been sent to Governor Jan Brewer for her signature or veto. As reported by The Los Angeles Times, most observers expect her to sign the bill. Brewer has until April 24 to act on the bill; if she neither signs nor vetoes the bill, it will become law within 90 days of the end of Arizona’s legislative session.

Arizona House Advances Strict Immigration Enforcement Bill

The New York Times reports that Arizona legislators have given preliminary approval to legislation that primarily concerns State enforcement of federal immigration laws. H.B. 2632, which is nearly identical to a bill passed in February by the state senate (S.B. 1070), would, among other things, allow police officers to charge illegal immigrants with criminal trespassing based solely on their presence in Arizona. The two bills must now go through reconciliation, which is expected to occur within the next two weeks.

Arizona Senate Passes Bill that Would Tighten Immigration Enforcement

AZCapitolTimes.com reports that Arizona’s senate, by a party-line 17-13 vote, passed a broad, immigration-focused bill covering a wide range of topics including law enforcement procedures, criminal law, and traffic congestion. The bill would:

  • require police officers to make a reasonable attempt to determine a person’s immigration status when “practicable;”
  • allow illegal immigrants to be charged with trespassing;
  • make it unlawful for anyone seeking work, regardless of their immigration status, to enter a vehicle stopped on the street;
  • penalize drivers who impede traffic in an attempt to hire a day laborer;
  • prohibit state and local governments from adopting policies that restrict the enforcement of immigration laws; and
  • require state and local governments to comply with, and assist in enforcing, federal immigration laws.

The bill now moves to Arizona’s house of representatives for consideration.

Supreme Court Solicits Administration's Stance on Arizona Law Aimed at Companies that Hire Undocumented Workers

The U.S. Supreme Court has asked the Solicitor General to submit a brief outlining the Obama administration’s stance on an Arizona law that punishes companies for hiring illegal immigrants, the Miami Herald reports. The justices will review this brief before deciding whether to hear a challenge to the law.

Continue Reading...