Obama May Encounter Difficulty Passing Immigration Reform

BusinessWeek reports that a troubled economy coupled with domestic concerns about jobs being lost to legal, and illegal, immigrants or through outsourcing make immigration reform a difficult campaign promise for President Obama to keep. Although Obama reaffirmed his commitment to the issue last week while meeting with pro-immigrant activists, his efforts might be stymied by a bill—co-sponsored by his former Illinois colleague, Senator Dick Durbin—that seeks to significantly limit the issuance of H-1B visas. Conversely, legislation that will be unveiled in the upcoming months by Senator Charles Schumer is expected to garner Obama’s support.

The debate comes at a time when immigration is in decline. The number of foreigners immigrating for school or work has decreased, and many presently residing in the U.S. are electing to leave because of a poor job market and visa hassles. As we noted earlier this month, more than one-third of H-1B visas for fiscal year 2009 remain available.

USCIS Conducting "Surprise" Work Site Visits to Tackle H-1B Visa Fraud

As reported by NetworkWorld, the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) has expanded its Administrative Site Visit and Verification Program to address fraud and abuses of H-1B and L-1 Visa programs by conducting unannounced work site inspections of companies that sponsor H-1B and L-1 Visa holders. Its Office of Fraud Detection and National Security estimates that 21% of H-1B visa petitions violate program rules. The shift comes as the Visa Reform Act - proposed federal legislation that will increase restrictions on and oversight of the issuance of non-immigrant professional visas – remains in congressional committee and employers examine visa alternatives should the legislation pass.

During “surprise visits,” USCIS assessors attempt to confirm the identities of a petitioning employer and visa recipient to verify that both have complied with the visa’s terms and conditions. Unlike the U.S. Department of Labor which has the statutory authority to investigate employer compliance with visa obligations, USCIS has no regulatory or statutory authority to enter workplaces of H-1B or L-1 Visa holders. USCIS officials have confirmed that complying with the investigation is voluntary. Previously only religious organizations were subject to mandatory inspections and reviews, however presently any non-immigrant petition might be subject to a workplace audit after approval and prior to any potential adjudication.

Investigators will request to interview the petitioner, review documents that support the visa application, and enter the workplace to visually confirm the recipient’s employment conforms to H-1B terms and conditions. Employers are not obligated to submit to disruptive or unreasonable requests for access to company employees or company property, but it is advisable that companies sponsoring foreign professionals prepare for potential visits by doing the following:

  • Prepare Audits in Advance
    • Identify who will provide records and what documents the company is willing to share with inspectors.
  • Have an H-1B Package which Includes:
    • Documentation showing that the recipient is receiving the prevailing wage for the occupation in the metropolitan area.
    • Documentation demonstrating how the employer determined the prevailing wage and that the recipient’s salary exceeds both that market wage and the actual wage it pays to other employees in similar roles.
    • A memo describing the factors (experience, qualifications, education, job responsibilities) considered to determine the wage.
    • Demonstrate that a posting for the recipient’s position, including salary and requirements, was publicly listed in two locations for 10 days.
    • Show that the company maintains a public access file that can be viewed by members of the public at any time with all relevant information to the visa.
  • Maintain Additional Information
    • Payroll records, data used to establish the position’s wage, copies of documents provided concerning employee benefits
  • Ensure Visa Petitions are Up-to-Date
    • If a visa employee’s wages or work location changes, an amended visa petition must be filed. 

Clinton Comments on Role of H-1B Visa Program in U.S./India Relations

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, speaking before the U.S.-India Business Council, outlined her plans for a “dramatic expansion” in U.S./India relations and touched upon concerns voiced by the Indian IT community and the Indian government that proposed restrictions on the H-1B visa program are a form of protectionism. As reported at Computerworld.com, Clinton remarked that both countries should "work through any issues in our relationships and differences in our perspectives by focusing on shared objectives and concrete results." Meera Shankar, India's ambassador to the United States, stated that India's IT talent has helped U.S. firms become more competitive globally, while also stimulating the U.S. economy by creating jobs and increasing profits.

Leader of Indian Software and IT Industry Association Visits Washington, D.C. to Discuss Immigration Policy

Som Mittal, president of Nasscom, the industry association representing Indian software and IT services firms, recently met in Washington, D.C. with various U.S. government officials and representatives of trade organizations. In an interview with InformationWeek, Mittal stated that he was in D.C. "to provide perspective on the Durbin-Grassley bill," bipartisan legislation aimed at preventing abuse and fraud in the H-1B and L-1 visa programs. Based on his meetings, Mittal said he thinks that the Obama administration and Congress are likely to consider H-1B and L-1 provisions as part of broader immigration reforms, perhaps later this year.

Mittal also noted that, from his perspective, the H-1B and L-1 visa programs should be considered matters of trade policy rather than immigration, stating: “Our data shows that [H-1B visa holders] stay in the U.S. less than two years.” He further commented:

Other countries, including the U.K., France, Germany, Japan, and India provide work permits to bring in foreign workers temporarily. It's not about immigration, it's about trade.

Bill Would Overhaul H-1B and L-1 Visa Programs

Last week Assistant Senate Majority Leader Richard Durbin (D-Ill.) and Sen. Charles Grassley (R-Iowa) introduced legislation that would completely reform the H-1B and L-1 visa guest worker programs. The H-1B and L-1 Visa Reform Act (S. 887) aims to close perceived loopholes in the programs that critics argue allow foreign workers to displace qualified Americans seeking the same employment.  Continue reading this entry on Littler's Washington DC Employment Law Update blog.